1 1/4 is industry standard for the shingles you have chosen. We use 1 1/2 nails for the hip and ridge, because a high end shingle is thicker than the old school 3-tab. One in nails were fine for those. Read your shingle warranty, it has verbage on the type and size of nails to be used.
Proper Roofing Nail Length
We are in the process of having a reroof done on a home in North Central Florida (six miles inland from coast) and have a question about proper roofing nail length.
That 1 1/4" roofer will punch through the decking by 3/8"-1/2", creating a safety hazard in the attic. Code appears vague only to require a 1/8" punch through for decking under 3/4". The roofing companies here seem to use 1 1/4" on most jobs. I can't get a clear answer on whether this is best practice, or just a matter of lazy convenience.
My question: Is there any advantage to using such a long nail for the complete job, vs using 1 inch for the field and 1 1/4 for hip and ridge? Having a punch-through of only 1/8" would minimize underdeck damage and increase safety.
Thanks for your input. I can elaborate as needed.
Mark
- Original roof will be stripped down to plywood.
- Decking is 1/2 inch (15/32) 4-ply CDX. Florida code calls for plywood to be renailed to 6" OC using 8d.
- Underlayment will be Atlas WeatherMaster 200 Water and Ice stick down.
- Shingles are Atlas Pinnacle Pristine architectural and Hip and Ridge.
That 1 1/4" roofer will punch through the decking by 3/8"-1/2", creating a safety hazard in the attic. Code appears vague only to require a 1/8" punch through for decking under 3/4". The roofing companies here seem to use 1 1/4" on most jobs. I can't get a clear answer on whether this is best practice, or just a matter of lazy convenience.
My question: Is there any advantage to using such a long nail for the complete job, vs using 1 inch for the field and 1 1/4 for hip and ridge? Having a punch-through of only 1/8" would minimize underdeck damage and increase safety.
Thanks for your input. I can elaborate as needed.
Mark
1 - 3 of 3 Posts
Thanks for your input on this, Roofermann. As you suggested, I did look at the Atlas warranty for the Pinnacle Pristine shingle (highlighted below) and in one part of the verbiage, it quotes code (1/8" punch through for decking below 3/4" thickness) and then later states the minimum nail length should be 1 1/4". This is a single layer reroof, same as a new application, so I have to assume the 1 1/4" length would apply. The warranty is important, and the installer is Atlas certified, so the extra length in the attic will have to be put up with.
From Atlas Warranty:
8.) FASTENING Placement of nails is critical to overall performance. High nail placement can result in separation of components and will cause delamination of the shingles after application. All nails must be driven straight with the heads flush to the shingle surface, never cutting into the shingle. Nails must not be exposed (visible) on the finished roof. Delamination after installation does not justify a warranty claim. FASTENERS: Nails must be 11 OR 12 gauge corrosion-resistant roofing nails with 3/8" minimum head. Nails must be long enough to penetrate the roof deck 3/4" or if the deck is less than 3/4" thick, the nails should be long enough to penetrate fully and extend at least 1/8" through the roof deck. Nails may be placed in the sealant line. NEW ROOFING APPLICATION (first shingle layer): 4 nails are required per shingle. The nails are to be located 7" up from the bottom edge of the shingle, with one nail placed approximately 1" from each side of the shingle, and the remaining two equally spaced between the two outer nails as illustrated in the diagram. NAILS MUST BE MINIMUM OF 1-1/4" LONG.
From Atlas Warranty:
8.) FASTENING Placement of nails is critical to overall performance. High nail placement can result in separation of components and will cause delamination of the shingles after application. All nails must be driven straight with the heads flush to the shingle surface, never cutting into the shingle. Nails must not be exposed (visible) on the finished roof. Delamination after installation does not justify a warranty claim. FASTENERS: Nails must be 11 OR 12 gauge corrosion-resistant roofing nails with 3/8" minimum head. Nails must be long enough to penetrate the roof deck 3/4" or if the deck is less than 3/4" thick, the nails should be long enough to penetrate fully and extend at least 1/8" through the roof deck. Nails may be placed in the sealant line. NEW ROOFING APPLICATION (first shingle layer): 4 nails are required per shingle. The nails are to be located 7" up from the bottom edge of the shingle, with one nail placed approximately 1" from each side of the shingle, and the remaining two equally spaced between the two outer nails as illustrated in the diagram. NAILS MUST BE MINIMUM OF 1-1/4" LONG.
1 - 3 of 3 Posts
Roofing Talk - Professional Roofing Contractors Forum
A forum community dedicated to professional roofers and enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about the industry, safety, finishing, tools, machinery, projects, styles, scales, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!
Full Forum Listing
